Why UK Buyers Choose Royal Mint Gold Coins Over Random Mint Issues
Share
If you are buying gold coins in the UK for collecting and tax efficiency, sticking to Royal Mint legal tender coins such as Sovereigns and Britannias is usually the smartest choice. Below we explain why, and where buyers often go wrong when they purchase from less recognised or so-called random mints.
1) CGT treatment: UK legal tender coins are exempt, foreign coins are not
Royal Mint coins like Sovereigns and Britannias are exempt from UK Capital Gains Tax (CGT) because they are sterling legal tender. That legal status means they fall outside CGT rules.
Foreign bullion coins, even from respected mints such as Canada, Australia, Mexico, South Africa or the United States, are not sterling currency. HMRC treats them as chargeable assets, so any profit on disposal can be subject to CGT. This is the single biggest difference that catches UK buyers out.
2) VAT: what is exempt and what is not
Investment gold, including qualifying coins from many countries, is exempt from VAT in the UK provided it meets HMRC’s criteria. The rules require a minimum fineness of 900/1000, minted after 1800, legal tender in its country, and priced within 180 percent of its intrinsic value.
This means a Canadian Maple or an Australian Kangaroo can be VAT free, but they will still not be CGT exempt. UK Royal Mint coins, however, benefit from both VAT exemption and CGT exemption.
3) Liquidity and spreads: recognisable UK coins sell faster
Royal Mint coins enjoy strong local demand in the UK. Dealers and private buyers recognise them instantly, which usually means tighter buy and sell spreads and faster resale compared to niche issues. On the other hand, obscure designs or private-mint rounds often come with wider spreads and slower resale because fewer buyers are familiar with them. Recognition drives liquidity.
4) Where “random mint” products can go wrong
Not all non-Royal Mint coins are poor choices. Coins like Maples, Eagles, Kangaroos and Libertads are high-quality pieces from established government mints. The problems arise with:
• Non-circulating commemoratives and private-mint medals or rounds marketed as “special editions”. These are often sold at inflated prices relative to metal value and can be confusingly described.
• Misunderstandings about legal tender status. In the UK, legal tender does not mean that banks or shops must accept a coin. It simply refers to settlement of debts in court.
• Face-value commemoratives compared to their metal content. Many widely advertised coins contain very little precious metal and can trade well below their original issue price.
• Replica or copy products that mimic classic designs. Unless struck by the official issuing authority, these are not true coins but medals, and resale demand can be very weak.
5) Design quality and authenticity
Unusual or novelty designs may look attractive, but that does not guarantee lasting collector demand. For long-term value and easy resale in the UK, the market consistently favours established British designs such as the Sovereign and Britannia, alongside major Royal Mint proof issues.
6) Quick reference: tax status for UK residents
| Coin type | VAT on purchase | CGT on disposal |
|---|---|---|
| Royal Mint, sterling legal tender (Sovereigns, Britannias, series like Queen’s or Tudor Beasts) | VAT-exempt as investment gold | CGT-exempt |
| Foreign government-mint bullion (Maple, Eagle, Kangaroo, Libertad, Krugerrand) | VAT-exempt if it meets HMRC’s investment gold definition | CGT-liable |
| Private-mint rounds or medals (not legal tender) | May not qualify as investment gold | CGT-liable |
7) A smart buying checklist
- Decide if CGT efficiency matters. If it does, stick to Royal Mint legal tender coins.
- Confirm VAT status. Ensure the coin meets the definition of investment gold.
- Avoid overpriced commemoratives. Check for clear fineness, genuine legal tender status, and a fair price.
- Favour recognisable types. Sovereigns and Britannias remain the most liquid in the UK.
- Keep records. Hold on to invoices and certificates to support resale and tax purposes.
8) So are foreign coins “bad”?
No. Coins from Canada, Australia, Mexico, the United States and other respected state mints are well made and widely collected. The key point for UK buyers is tax. They are generally not CGT exempt, whereas Royal Mint coins are. For UK residents seeking both collectability and tax efficiency, Sovereigns and Britannias remain the most straightforward choice.
9) Summary
• Royal Mint legal tender coins such as Sovereigns and Britannias are both VAT-exempt investment gold and CGT-exempt for UK residents.
• Foreign bullion coins such as Maples, Eagles, Kangaroos, Libertads and Krugerrands are VAT-exempt if they qualify but are not CGT-exempt in the UK.
• Be wary of highly promoted commemoratives or replicas that are often overpriced, confusing in status and weaker on resale.
